Tuesday, January 25, 2022

A Deficiency That Keeps Coming Back to Bite Us.

Mention of this problem was first made recently in this blog regarding traffic problems, and car accidents, on 6th Avenue.  Whether it was speed, distraction (my guess was mobile phones), or various causes of carelessness, it seemed we weren't enforcing enough.  And "enough" really has two operational indicators.  By definition, we weren't enforcing "enough" to prevent all the accidents.  But even as a Village theme, and a historical one, we weren't enforcing as much as we used to, when we told everyone, and were known for it, "Don't Even Think About Speeding."  Our ticket-writing statistics proved we meant it.  (Art Gonzalez dug up statistics to show how drastically our enforcement fell apart in recent years.). In the old enforcement days, if drivers did the next thing after thinking about speeding -- they sped -- they got ticketed.  And not only did they get a ticket, but they also got the message.

Now, we're talking about one particular issue, which is the driveways and swales Ordinance (update), and we're again noting some requirements that are not new, but also not followed.  They haven't been followed on some properties for several or many decades.  They're not followed, because we don't enforce even the Ordinance we already have.

There are some long time Village residents who will tell you that failure to follow rules, and lack of enforcement of those rules, has noteworthy consequences for how the Village looks.

What's unfortunate, and perhaps moreso now, as values/assessments and prices are climbing, is that some people chose to live in BP, because it was cheaper to buy a house here than it would have been to buy one in, let's say, Miami Shores.  And it was cheaper to buy a house here, because BP is not as nice a municipality as is the Shores, because we don't enforce enough to make it nicer.  Those people presumably didn't want to have to follow rules, and pay the cost of following them.  So, the people who are spending more now are living in a municipality that isn't as nice as it should be, because we don't bother to follow, or enforce, our own rules.  We don't do it on 6th Avenue, and we don't do it anywhere.  (It's true the speed limit on 6th Avenue isn't our own rule, but if we had had our way, the limit would be lower than it is, and we would still not be enforcing it.  At the cost of cars, physical health of drivers, and security of people who live on 6th Avenue.)

It's maybe not entirely clear whose fault this is.   In theory, it's the manager's fault, since the manager controls the police chief, and the police chief controls the police.  And the manager also controls the Code Compliance Officer.  But the Commission exerts very important control over the manager, including choosing which manager candidate to hire (and what to tell him or her is really important to us), and whether or not to retain the hired manager, so maybe it's the Commission's fault, too.

In any event, we seem to be sort of globally falling down on the job of enforcement, about most things in BP.  We still pay property taxes, though, so there's a disturbing disconnect somewhere.  To put it one way, we're not getting what we're paying for.


7 comments:

  1. Fred - Biscayne Park fails to follow its own code and rules for property it owns and controls. And it hasn't for as long as we have lived here .. long enough to be characterized as its mode of operation. Everyone else is just following that example.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Drew, boy, are you preaching to the choir.

      Fred

      Delete
  2. It's an interesting thing about this post. I've gotten a lot more feedback about it than just Drew Dillworth's comment, but the people who have reached out, in agreement with what I said, don't want to be public about their opinions. I got some very extensive text messages from one person.

    And a few people complained, curiously, about Mac Kennedy. No one seemed to disagree with Mac's agenda, but they complained that Mac is provocative (he is) and fills a room with himself (he does), but doesn't get things done. As I've tried to tell them, Mac is one of five Commissioners. He can't force things to get done, if his Commission colleagues are brain dead (which they are). And I'm not saying Mac is the greatest thing since sliced bread (Roxy Ross is, and so is Chuck Ross), but he attracts more criticism than he technically deserves. I certainly agree that if Mac toned himself down, he'd be less of a lightning rod, but it's still not his fault that he's the only one of five current Commissioners who wants anything adaptive or constructive for the Village. He's the only one of the current bunch who wants the Village to be better than it is. Which is increasingly conspicuously not great. One person even told me CNM is improving itself more than we are. That's pretty embarrassing for us. It used to be that the best thing we could say on our behalf was that "we're not CNM." Now, "we're not CNM" is just another admission of our failure.

    Fred

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am totally cool with folks complaining about my style (it's not for everyone, but whose is ... and "complete lack of" is the worst style of all, IMO) or about the substance that I bring to the commission. I wish those folk would be as critical about the commissioners who bring absolutely nothing to the table and who contribute few ideas before they vote on mine or on the items brought by the manager. We have lazy commissioners who lack skills for critical thinking, and that's scary AF for me as a resident and frustrating AF as a commissioner. See, there's that brash style that doesn't sit well! Regarding the "Mac doesn't get anything done" comment, that person is off by a long shot and likely hung up on the "style" issue. I have better things to do today while riding out a blizzard in Boston than to compile that list here. "Better things" includes polishing my input for the "swale" topic for the February commission meeting and playing in the snow with my nephews. Whoever is questioning my productivity can go back through two years worth of commission meeting agenda and look for themselves ... and they can talk with me directly to discuss any of the history and the current projects that I have on the table. I make myself very available to residents.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mac,

      As you very rightly say, everyone has his or her style. Others can like it or not. I'm not sure that's relevant in comparison to someone's dedication, intelligence, wisdom, and intent to get things done.

      I don't think anyone ever complained, and certainly never should have, that you don't get things done. First of all, you are very intent to get things done. Second of all, you yourself can't do anything without a majority of the Commission. And you have again very rightly described them. You have both hands tied behind your back, and you're blindfolded, and you're still trying to improve this Village. It's a wonder what all the people who voted for you did with their other votes. Gave them to Ginny, Dan, Art, and Judi? And the point of that was what?

      Yes, I heard about the blizzard. My daughter lives in Medfield (southeast of Boston), and I heard yesterday it was coming. I'm sure I'll hear more today. Boy, am I glad I'm done with living up north (in Massachusetts).

      Keep up the great work. You know I've pleaded with you to tone yourself down, because I want you to engage more of your so-called colleagues, so we can get more done. You are the leader of the Commission. You are the only one with adaptive, constructive, and progressive ideas. Do I in reality think there's anything you could do that would allow people whose only reasons for being there are...being there to allow you with enthusiasm and appreciation to take the lead? No. They're incapable of it, and they're truly all about themselves. It's still a wonder to me that we elect this kind of nonsense. And we've done it with pretty good consistency since 2016.

      Fred

      Delete
  4. We have an election in November with three seats to fill. We need people with the smarts and interest to help. It's not easy, but it is quite satisfying and fun. Lots of reading each month, if you actually read agenda items, contracts, etc. in preparation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you in large part: it's not easy, it's satisfying, and it requires various kinds of hard work, including reading. It is not, however, fun, at least in my experience. But then again, neither is my "day job," which is also not easy, but satisfying, and requires a lot of hard work. "Fun," for me, is other things.

      Fred

      Delete