Saturday, November 30, 2013

Here's My Plan

My central aim is to keep the Village alive and thriving.  This is essential.  I like where and how I live, we all like our neighborhood, and keeping it the way it is, or improving it, takes our being independent.  We must call our own shots.

We need better fiscal support.  We could raise taxes as high as is necessary, but few have much enthusiasm for super-taxes.  And even if we decided it was the best thing for us to do, we could not plan a future that way, because future Commissions and residents might not agree.  It's unstable.  It also depends on healthy and endlessly increasing property values, and we've already seen how unstable that is.

Grants are good, and they're valuable.  They're also not easy to come by, they're very specific, they're not repeating, and they typically require us to match them.  And, given the right, or the wrong, Governor, the plug can get pulled just when we think we have one of these grants, as we have recently seen.  We cannot plan a future on the hope of living off grants.

We have economized valiantly.  We have no meaningful fat in the budget.  In that we are already unable to meet our responsibilities as a municipality, it makes little sense to try to confront our fiscal problems by seeing if we can do even less.

We very simply need more income.  We need to stabilize our budget, we need to preserve what's great about Biscayne Park, and we need to improve.  All of that takes money the Village does not now have. Our best opportunity to reinvent ourselves is presented by the possibility of annexing.  We must explore and pursue this possibility.  Every relevant professional and knowledgeable person who has crossed our path has told us that.  If, as the ante is raised, we are reassured that annexation is a good and workable idea for us, we have to do it.  If we find out it will not do for us what we need it to do, we have to "know when to fold 'em" and walk away.  We cannot answer the questions without being part of the process.

There is no sense in trying to create our own tiny commercial component next to the log cabin.  First of all, such a plan directly defies the reasons some of us don't want to annex something else.  It very materially and considerably changes the Park in exactly the direction annexation opponents do not want to go.  Second, those opponents also criticize the primary annexation plan, because of what they describe as inadequate information.  There is absolutely no information as to what could possibly be expected from the construction of a small office and storefront building, and no reason at all to think it would produce remotely meaningful income for the Village.  Third, such a scheme aggravates the traffic problem of which annexation opponents complain.

The question is, what if we cannot annex.  The answer is that we may be sunk, or it may be that we will have to try a very different approach to saving ourselves.  If, as some suggest, we had to rely on unusually high property values to produce more substantial revenues, then we would have to do something to raise value.  And there's no reason we shouldn't do that anyway.

To improve ourselves this way, we must improve and enhance the condition of the neighborhood.  We need to improve, through development and furnishing, our public spaces.  Dan Keys and Parks and Parkways have begun some of this, with the landscaping improvements around our entrance sign and at the entrance to the recreation center building.  We need more.  We need first rate medians.  We need all our public spaces to be impressive.

We also need individual private properties to be brought up to appropriate and respectable condition.   We need Codes that permit our neighbors to keep properties in a way that fulfills them, while respecting all of us and the style and standard of the neighborhood we share.  And we need strict adherence to those Codes.  We need our Boards and our Commissions to unite in raising the standard of the neighborhood so that it's a credit to all of us and a place we can all be proud of.

This raises the further problem of gradual alienation of Park residents.  Ironically it is those residents and neighbors who have been most active and most devoted who are being most alienated.  We need to welcome and enable resident/neighbor participation, not deflect and frustrate it.  In my Commission campaign, I have met BP residents who are clamoring to participate and to help out, while Board seats sit empty, and some Commissioners refuse to fill them and instead talk about minimizing or suspending the Boards.  This is an inclusive neighborhood.  We need to engage the eager, resourceful, and dedicated.  We need to help stragglers and marginal neighbors, not create more of them.

Our signature log cabin needs action.  In my opinion, the preferred action is to renovate it.  It can serve as the seat of Village functioning, including, as in years past, hosting our meetings.  It also needs expansion, so that it can house all municipal and administrative functions, including the Biscayne Park Police.  All it takes is what we do not now have: money.  We can get money by raising taxes, assessing ourselves, or annexing other tracts.  But we must find the money.  I'm not afraid, and I do not surrender.

With an outdoor sculpture and a mural now owned and proudly displayed by the Village, and another sculpture awaiting delivery, we have every reason to expand a real public art program.  I strongly advocate for a program like this.  It brings class, self-respect, and broad enrichment to municipalities.  And I pledge never to take Village money for such a program without a clear consensus that this is what residents want to do with their taxes.

We should continue to consider whether there may be real and substantial value to erecting a wall along the train track.  Construction like that would no doubt be very expensive, but it may be very worthwhile, to increase quality of life for our neighbors who live along the track and for all of us.  Improved quality of life increases the commitment, dedication, and investment of property owners, which increases the condition of properties, which increases value as well as comfort.  This is what we want.

We have a wonderful Village.  We have some great neighbors.  For as long as we want to promote and encourage it, we happen to have the best police department in the state.  If we thought our police accomplishment was due to Mitch Glansberg, or Ana Garcia, or Ray Atesiano, two of them no longer work here, and the other will eventually retire, or get lured away by someone else.  The individuals won't stay forever, but our commitment can.

We just need to take a deep breath, and develop vision and the courage to pursue it.  That's my plan.


"For the Best We Can Be."

Thursday, November 28, 2013

New Math

It appears agreed that the Village is in fiscal trouble.  We spend more than we make, and/or we do not have enough money to pay for the kinds of things a successful municipality must do.  Various people have described this problem in various ways, and a range of suggestions have been made to correct it.  At most dire, some feel either that the municipality will become defunct in up to 10 years, or that it will be annexed, presumably either by North Miami or by Miami Shores.  Neither of those municipalities, by the way, has any reason to want to absorb the erstwhile Village of Biscayne park.  We would be the same fiscal problem to them that we are to ourselves.

Standard approaches to our problem have included solutions like raising taxes, economizing more, and annexing some other tract of land and land use.  Each one makes a certain kind of sense, with some being a bit more sensible, or workable, than others.

But very recently, I heard two other approaches.  They are creative, unusual, and perhaps even counter-intuitive.  I always like thinking "outside the box," so approaches like these grab my attention.

The first of these approaches was suggested by Noah Jacobs.  Noah, by the way, is one of those people who says he recognizes that we are in fiscal trouble.  His recommendation was summarized at the special Commission meeting to negotiate salary and benefits with our new Manager.  There were actually two orders of business at that meeting.  The second was the Manager's contract, and the first was acceptance of the ad valorem tax rate and the coming year budget.  Noah had two proposals.  One was an objection to the tax rate and budget (he voted against both of them), and he reminded us of his wish for lower taxes.  The other was persistently, at each and every instance, to advocate in favor of any salary or benefit concession the new Manager requested.  So Noah's solution to the Village's fiscal problem, the problem that can be summarized as the Village's spending more than it makes, was to have it make less and spend more.  I told you this might seem counter-intuitive.

The other approach was shared by someone who brings fresh eyes to our problem.  Manny Espinoza is a very new BP resident.  He's been here for about 13 months now.  But he's fallen in love with the Park already, and he decided that he should be a Commissioner by now.  He already identified one problem, which was that the P&Z Board and the Commission did not think he should have a fence in front of his house.  It may even be that he will, in time, discover other imperfections.  But the present issue is that it just so happens that Manny is an accountant.  Manny informed us at the candidates' forum that in that he is an accountant, once he takes office, money will simply appear.  He didn't use the term "magic wand," but that was the sense I got in listening to him.  Or maybe he just meant that he is a devotee of "creative accounting."

So those of us who look at fiscal situations, and address them with standard addition and subtraction, may have it all wrong.  We may be suffering from lack of creativity, or the confinement of conventional thinking.  Adam Smith's "invisible hand" theory was intended to suggest that capitalist systems find their own homeostases and thereby regulate themselves.  The "invisible hand" theory "on crack" may suggest the possibility of entirely alternative realities, where amplifying deficits somehow resolves them, or money grows on trees or falls from the sky.

Wednesday, November 27, 2013

biscayneparkshame@yahoo.com

Today, the third installment of "biscayneparkpride@yahoo.com" was sent to some collection of people.  This one was like the first one, in that it was not fact-based.  In fact, there was not one correct assertion in the whole letter.  It was different from the other two, however, in that it was signed.  The person who sent it was Kelvyn Whitfield, and he included his street address, instead of the impersonation of the Village address that was listed on the other two mailings.  Like the other two, this one was sent not directly, but through "ConstantContact."

I went to see Kelvyn at his house this morning.  I asked him about the letter he sent out, but he said he didn't want to talk about it.  He did acknowledge having sent it.  I pointed out to him that not one of the assertions contained in his letter was true.  He said he considered them all to be true.  I reminded him that he almost never appears at Commission meetings, making it unlikely that he would know what happens there, but he said he sometimes watches them, presumably on Comcast.  When I persevered, and told him that the things he claimed were true and happened were not true and did not happen, he said it was not possible for anyone to check facts about someone else.  I disagreed, and I offered to show him proof of what was actually true.  He wasn't interested, he "didn't care," and he said he accepted it as his mission to save the Village from poor Commissioners.  I pointed out that I am not a Commissioner and am therefore not to blame for whatever are his complaints about the Commission.  He fell silent.

Recognizing that Kelvyn could not be relying on anything he personally witnessed or knew, and further recognizing that the material he sent out was eerily similar to the complaints of certain other people, I suggested to Kelvyn that perhaps he was relying on what someone else told him.  I wondered who that someone might be.  "I don't have to tell you," countered Kelvyn.  True enough.  And for what it's worth, Kelvyn pointed out to me today that he is "not a child."

The other interesting fact about my conversation with Kelvyn today is that apparently, if what Kelvyn says is true, he did not receive the other two biscayneparkpride/ConstantContact letters.  He has not previously been included in this campaign.  Thus, it appears someone has come to Kelvyn, presumably provided him with something to circulate, and told him it was now his turn.  Clearly, he doesn't know anything about any of this, including the contents of the letter he signed.

Let's all await the election eve drive-by anonymous bill of accusations, not to mention more installments in the biscayneparkpride@yahoo.com/ConstantContact series.  (Interestingly, biscayneparkpride has been decommissioned by yahoo, so it's unclear how it was used to send out today's missive.)  It's beginning to look like it will be about Roxy Ross and me this year, or perhaps, if we can take Kelvyn as an indication, the "Jonas-Ross Ticket," whatever that is.

Monday, November 25, 2013

Can I Interest You in a Piece of Public Sculpture?


Persistent?  Incorrigible?  Suit yourself.  If there's a problem, tell me what it is.  One Commission agreed to accept a gift of public sculpture for the Village, and a very different Commission agreed to accept another.  Now, I'm on the trail of a third, which I'll come to shortly.

For an important piece of perspective about what probably appears to be my project, between the first piece and the second, Gage Hartung suggested a sculptor of whom I had not known.  I found the sculptor, and I met with him.  He was a very interesting guy, and his sculptures were magnificent.  They were also very pricey.  So much so that there was no chance we (a few donors) could raise that kind of money.  So it was a great idea, but I couldn't make it work.  As I was wrapping up raising funds for the second sculpture, David Tunnell said he preferred something more "organic" for the Village.  His image was something maybe made of stone, with a rounded contour and an abstract representation. I don't know of such pieces, and I asked David to find one, or to help me find one.  He did not get back to me.  So I can understand why it seems like I'm driving this bus, but I'm going to plead not guilty.  I would be more than delighted to have someone else take over the choosing and the fund-raising.

Cecilia Lueza painted our new mural at the recreation center.  If you go to her website, lueza.com, you will see other murals she has painted.  You will also see paintings intended for indoors.  And you will see outdoor sculptures.  As it happens, I saw a series of her sculptures last year at Art Miami (the design district/Wynwood branch of Art Basel).  I didn't know they were hers, and I had never heard of her before.  They were very captivating pieces, however, and I recognized them instantly when I saw her site.  They are the series of three face profiles.  Now that I've seen her site, I can say they are not at all the only pieces I think would be great in BP.

Here's an example of what I have in mind.  I've spoken to Cecilia about this, and she's offered us a discount.



The sizes and materials are 8 feet aluminum, 11 feet aluminum, 10 feet aluminum and urethane, 8 feet aluminum and urethane, over 8 feet aluminum and urethane, and 9 feet aluminum, steel, and urethane.

These are not easy, although $5000, the price for the third one down, is what we paid for the second sculpture we got.  So not out of sight for "Ascending."  My favorites are the two "Diversity," or triple faces, series.  The "Tower of Seasons," the ones with the colored circular discs, are appealing, and the shorter one may be accessible, cost-wise.  I like "Dual Nature," the multi-colored head, very much, but it's expensive for us.  Cecilia has more.  These are just the ones I liked best.  Go to her site, and see if something else appeals to you.

When I ask "Can I Interest You..." I mean would you contribute to paying for these.  I have every reason to assume the fund-raising for another sculpture would be the same as it was for the other two pieces.  As you know, I'm running for Commissioner, and I will promise you I would never make a move against the Village coffers to pay for something like this.  What I absolutely would do is canvass the neighborhood and the Commission, and place the matter on an agenda, or better yet, a workshop, to see if BP residents would like to pay a yearly assessment for public art.  Just to remind you, it would cost about $1.66 (that's one dollar and sixty-six cents) per person in BP to collect enough money to buy a $5000 piece of art.  For a $10K piece, it's about $3.35 per person.  Once, or once a year.  So we're talking about meaningless amounts of money.    If we wanted to skip the concept of counting heads, and just go to households, we could call it $5-$10 per house, and we collect about $6K-$12K.  If we got really ambitious, and collected $20 per house, we would have a very nice public art program pretty quickly.

So let me know what you think.  Do you like the idea?  Do you happen to like these pieces?  Do you like the idea, but you have some other pieces in mind?  Tell me about them, and where they are, and how much we would have to pay for them.  I'll go inquire, or haggle.  Or you do it, and tell me how I can help.

Friday, November 22, 2013

A Very Bad Sign.

My day started with a call from a supporter who had accepted one of my yard signs.  She left me a message to say that it seems the wind or the rain must have blown my yard sign away.  The wire stand was still in the ground, but the sign was gone.  The sign from one of my competitors, Manny Espinoza, must have been sturdier.  It was still there.  Furthermore, my supporter observed, a yard sign for Roxy Ross, which had been across the street, was also gone.  Elsewhere on 119th Street, not far from where my supporter lives, signs for Roxy and David Coviello, were gone.  Only a sign for Manny Espinoza remained.  A block away, at 119th and 9th, Roxy Ross' sign and my sign were gone, and only Noah Jacobs' remained.

Last Sunday, I replaced a sign on 111th Street.  By Monday, a day later, the replacement was gone.

Today, Noah Jacobs sent around a plea for assistance from whoever is on his circulation list.  He wants "walkers and talkers," and he adds that he's "being accused of things [he's] never done nor would [he] do."  Without his supporters' help, he pleads or admonishes, Biscayne Park "will end up with Commissioners that none of us want."

Among candidates Noah would like to accuse of something or other, there is probably no one as outspoken as I am.  I have never said an out of the way or criticizing word about Noah during my campaigning, nor would I, nor do any of the others, as best I can tell.  We all have enough to do to explain our own positions about the issues.  No one asks me about other candidates, and I don't discuss them, either to criticize them or to praise or support them.

So either people are inexplicably telling Noah something that is in no way true, or Noah is telling his circulation list, and anyone else who reads what he writes, something that is in no way true.

As for the Village ending up with Commissioners Noah deems unwanted by any BP residents, could I take the liberty to suggest that that is Noah's distorted and self-serving opinion?  Is it possible that Noah is so frantic that he resorts to this kind of misrepresentation because the Village already has some Commissioners people don't want?  The fact is, everyone running for office feels he or she is more desirable, or has more to offer, than others running.  Why else would anyone run?  Is it really necessary to try to whip people into a frenzy of antipathy toward unnamed evil-doers, just to make the case that one should be elected, or re-elected?  Is Noah's best argument for why people should vote for him that his competition is toxic to the neighborhood, or at least that no one would want them?  And is he having to tell people that they don't want his competition, because he thinks people are too stupid to decide that for themselves?

I can't help but think back to Gaspar Gonzalez's column, in which he wrote about the friendliness and the spirit of cooperation and single-mindedness of purpose of BP residents.  He said it was the reason he chose to live here.  Or the argument made by Barbara Watts and Steve Bernard, as to why we shouldn't have combined the BP election with the general election: it would take that small town, quaint, friendly feeling out of the campaign and election process.

It appears Noah isn't in line with me, with most of the other candidates, with Gaspar, with Barbara, with Steve, or perhaps with anyone.  He seems to be cultivating a rogue position from which he resorts to anything and takes swipes at anyone.  Maybe at everyone.  He never tells us who he believes, or alleges, "accused [him] of things."  I'm reminded of Noah himself, too, and his comment about being nothing more than reactive.  There is no agenda, no purpose, only reaction.  Friendliness?  Spirit of cooperation?  No, I wouldn't think so.  More like pervasive disdain, divisiveness, underhandedness, and dishonesty.

I guess it's going to be a long week and a half until the election.


Happy Anniversary, More or Less

I don't know how or if BP residents celebrated the 25th and 50th anniversaries of the Village.  In 1958, the year of the 25th anniversary, men wore suits and slicked their hair, women wore dresses and high-heeled shoes and had their hair done, very many people smoked, and celebrations of many things had a formal tone to them.  I remember my own parents' involvement in outings like these.  I'm imagining a cocktail party, at least, if not a full banquet.

In 1983, the year of the 50th anniversary, people still enjoyed celebratory get-togethers.  In the Village, there was a vibrant garden club.  My first BP next door neighbor, Lois Roberts, had been very active in the garden club.  There was also an active sense of community here.  I can only imagine there must have been some eager marking of the BP "half century."  On the other hand, I have asked two families who lived here in 1983.  One imagines he might have been at the 50th, if there was one (he doesn't remember), and he wonders if that was the time Ed Burke rode down the street on an elephant.  The other family doesn't remember any celebration of the 50th and suspects there wasn't one.

I moved here in 2005, and the 75th anniversary was in 2008.  The "party" was held at the Miami Shores Country Club and included a dinner, a lecture on local history, and a floor show.  We all dressed up, and the event doubled as a fund-raiser for the Village.  The program was devised and planned by a group of BP residents who worked for months on it.  One of the planners was the then Mayor.

It's not clear why an 80th anniversary event was planned.  Some BPers say they think an 80th anniversary is not worthy of much fanfare.  Maybe others just like to celebrate: if we like to party, who cares what the excuse is?  Planning was executed by the team of Candido Sosa-Cruz and Barbara Watts, who relied on historical interest grants for all funding.

The plan for the celebration became informal.  The date, a Friday, instead of the Saturday we might have expected, conflicted with an intended Food and Tunes, which turned out to be symbolic.  The 80th anniversary schedule much more closely resembled a glorified Food and Tunes itself than it did a gala.  Added were the presentation of a mural, an event partially tainted by a faulty process, a lecture presented by a different historian than five years ago (very lively and well-received), a concert by a symphonic band from North Miami, and a flag football game the next day, contested by our PW/Recreation staff and our police.  Vendors sold arts and crafts both days.  Two vendors, our own David Blake and Tim Tierney, sold comestibles.  David is marketing specialty coffee and chocolate, and Tim is selling pickled produce he prepared himself.  (Both were very good.)

The Saturday chapter of the 80th anniversary celebration was essentially rained out.  No one's fault, but also symbolic never-the-less.

Maybe the event-planning suffered from the decision not to involve the people who care, or theoretically would care, the most: BP residents.  During the most recent similar opportunity, BPers  wanted something more upscale.  Maybe, as some BP residents have said, the 80th anniversary simply did not carry the emotional impact to make it worthy of much hullabaloo.  Whatever attracted people, or would have attracted them, it was a nice evening.  The lecture was a nice feature, the band was very good, and if you like food truck food, you ate adequately.

The 80th anniversary celebration seems either to have been too little or too much.  Either it deserved more elaborate planning and greater pomp, or it was an exaggerated response to a minor marker.  The other possibility, that few of us might want to consider, is that it was just right.  As with a person, an 80th birthday is well worth noting, because of the decreasing likelihood of more birthdays, or of many more of them.  At that age, we take what we can get.  The same is being said of Biscayne Park.  Lifespan numbers have been mentioned lately.  Ten more years to live.  Maybe less than 10.  If that's what's ahead of us, sure, we'll seize the 80th.  Maybe we should make a plan for an 81st.

Thursday, November 21, 2013

Mural, Mural, on the Wall. A Saga in Two Parts: Part III

I like it.  It's peaceful, and it depicts some of our local birds.  It was nicely done.  It's not at all imposing, and I think the people who will see it the most, especially including the people who live across from it, will be pleased it's there.  Presumably, we'll hear more, including from them, over time.

The mural cost the Village coffers $2000, and that little only because of $500 in private donations from residents.  The last complaint about this was at the Wednesday night, 11/20/13, Commission meeting.  Two of the three Commissioners who raided the Village coffers to pay for the mural, over the unanimous objection of Village residents who expressed themselves, weren't at the meeting, which was for the insignificant purpose of negotiating a contract with our new manager.  What Commissioner would bother to attend a meeting as unimportant as that?  Well, Ross and Anderson did.  And Jacobs came a few minutes late.  So at least there was a quorum.  In fact, a quorum was all there was.

I had a mural painted at my house, on a wall no one can see unless they're at my house, and they stand on the deck in back of the house.  My mural is much more elaborate, much more detailed, much more complicated, and possibly larger in square feet than the mural at the recreation center.  The muralist charged me $1000.  But then again, I didn't say in advance that I had a $5000 budget.

Our mural, the Village's mural at the recreation center, will be unveiled on Friday, November 22, at the 80th anniversary event.  Festivities start at 6:00 PM.  The official unveiling is at 6:30.  If you can stay later, you'll hear a lecture on the history of Biscayne Park at 7:00 and a band concert at 8:00.  Come by and see the mural.  I do think you'll like it.


PS:  Here's a question I didn't ask.  Three Commissioners, Watts, Jacobs, and Cooper, agreed to take most of the cost of the mural from the Village coffers.  This was over the vigorous and persistent objection of every BP resident who voiced an opinion about it.  These three Commissioners were willing to raid the Village coffers and take the entire $2500.  They didn't have to take quite that much, because of private donations totaling about $500.  So the question is, did these three Commissioners have the decency, respect, and consideration to put their money where their mouths were?  Did they themselves contribute privately?  How much did each contribute to the mural?  They did, after all, take our tax money, when we kept pleading with them not to.  Were they at least honorable enough to lighten the load they insisted upon placing on the Village?

It's Starting Already? It's Going to Be One of Those Fortnights.

One of our sadder BP election traditions is the election eve drive-by screed.  It's on one or both sides of a piece of paper typed and photocopied for all of us, and it's unsigned.  It features a spate of allegations, usually of nefarious and scandalous "facts" about the candidate referenced.

The two distinguishing features of this communication are that it is anonymous, and that it is presented at a time when the victim cannot address any of the allegations: the night before the election.  In this sense, it is both cowardly (and illegal, interestingly enough) and underhanded.  I have also never seen one of these in which I had confidence the assertions were true.

I fully expect to be the subject/victim of one of these myself this year.  I doubt anyone will allege that I am a drug addict, child molester, or former embezzler, but I would expect, based on the kind of material typically presented, and the bent of the person who I think is behind these, some quotes from this blog.  The fact is, I was going to mention to you just before the election that you should expect this screed, and you should consider 1) that it is unattributed/unsigned, and 2) that it is strategically circulated at a time that it cannot be responded to.  So take it for what it appears to be worth, and the fact that whoever initiates it does not have the courage, honesty, and decency to tell you who he or she is.

But this year, we apparently have a variation on the theme, as they say.  This year, there is an e-mail circulation (I'm not sure how wide the circulation was-- two people sent it to me) about Roxy Ross and an anti-bullying Resolution.  The e-mail says that Roxy Ross "doesn't seem to comprehend the severity of this [bullying] problem," that she "refused to support an amendment to the Resolution against bullying of adults and...[Village] employees," that she "only supported efforts against bullying of children!" (the author adds the quotation mark, showing how outrageous he/she thinks it is that Roxy Ross objects to bullying of children), and that she "fought against [an] amendment that would've resulted in a win-win compromise."

"She absolutely refused to compromise, " our guerrilla tells us, "thereby undermining...efficiency in government."  Had Roxy Ross acceded to amendments and "compromises," we're told, "it would've saved our citizens tax dollars which must now be spent on Village staff and legal counsel which will have to hear another Resolution on bullying."

If you attended Village Commission meetings, you would know which Commissioner nurses grudges about irrelevant details forever, who is terribly hung up on the concept of imagined bullying of Village employees, who very typically distorts and perverts the positions of others to contort them into their precise opposites, and who is seemingly in love with wasting Village money on legal wild goose chases.  It was in fact Roxy Ross who introduced the anti-bullying Resolution, it was Roxy who championed it, Roxy wrote it herself, using her legal skills and training and saving the Village the cost of having our attorney do it, and Roxy who attempted to consider amendments, until the amendments required wholesale reworking of the entire Resolution.  It was at that point that Roxy suggested to the obsessed Commissioner that he redo her Resolution himself.  As you can see from his comments, he is fond of criticizing, but not fond of work.

So I'm sorry to have to observe that it has apparently started, and almost two weeks in advance.  Unfortunately, but not at all atypically or unexpectedly, the e-circulation is not revealed, so Roxy can counter the distortions and dishonest implications, but she cannot communicate this to the people who received the e-mail.  She has no way to know who they are.

I suppose we should assume there is more to come.  Our brave and honest correspondent calls him- or herself biscayneparkpride@yahoo.com.  I'm not sure where "pride" comes into it, but at least we're provided with an anonymous e-mail source for this pathetic nonsense.

By the way, as I told you regarding vandalism or theft of campaign signs, circulating of material like this anonymously and without a permit is not legal.  If you happen to see the distributing rats scurrying around with the paper version, see if you know who they are, or get any description you can, and call our police.  They will very much want to know.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

What Could You Expect?

The question raised is a very good one.  In fact, it's an excellent and extremely appropriate one.  Anyone who does not raise this question is not paying attention or thinking clearly.

The question is, if I am outspoken in this blog, and in my limited opportunity to make "public comments" at Commission meetings, what would I be like if I myself were a Commissioner?  Would I be hostile, unrestrained, challenging?  Is it not situational, but rather my nature to confront?

Great question.  I appreciate your asking.

The answers are as follows: I have been a fully-fledged member of the Planning and Zoning Board, the Code Review Committee, and I am now a Trustee of the Biscayne Park Foundation.  In fact, I'm the President of the Foundation, to the extent that offices and titles mean anything.  Each assignment has been for at least two to three years.  I left P&Z, because I thought someone else could do a better job than I could, and I left Code Review to join the Foundation, and because I had nothing else useful to add.  My colleagues have included Gage Hartung, Andrew Olis, Elizabeth Piotrowski-Hornbuckle, Mario Rumiano, Al Childress, Harvey Bilt, Judi Hamelburg, Lily Harper, Sira Ramos, Dan Keys, Kelly Romano, Gary Kuhl, Steve Taylor, Supreme Dorvil, Victor Romano, Joe Chao, Chuck Ross, Marie Smith, and some others whom I can't remember from Code Review at the moment.  If anyone were to ask me the question, I would say I believe I had excellent working relationships with all of them, though we did not and do not necessarily agree about things.  I count many as friends, some as close friends, and I don't think there are any with whom I do not have a good relationship.  If you think I'm overlooking something, I just gave you a list of people you can ask for confirmation.

I have on occasion been openly critical, in writing and during public comment at Commission meetings, of some Commissioners who have resisted or suppressed Steve Bernard and Bryan Cooper for no other reason than that they were Steve and Bryan.  And I have seen this happen.  I understand how easy it is, considering the affront and the offense represented by Steve and Bryan, and Noah Jacobs and Barbara Watts, to resist them simply because they are who they are, but I consider it unfair and not in the best interests of the Village to treat them this way.  And the fact that all of them treat the rest of the Commission, and residents like me, this way does not change my position that they should be heard and their suggestions given genuine consideration.

I have also demonstrated an ability to listen to others, even people with whom I do not necessarily agree, and I can come to new understandings about things.  I am capable of changing my mind, given a reasonable and compelling argument.  I also believe in the democratic process, and I would uphold the will of the majority and our established rules, even if I would personally not prefer them.  I never ask someone to believe me, just because I assert something, or because the person likes or is inclined to trust me.  I encourage people to question and to look for opposing evidence, and I will help them find it.  One of my friends sometimes chides me for always presenting both sides of an issue.  A decision or conclusion needs to respect all considerations, not just one side of a story.

So although I think the question is a reasonable and frankly good one, I do not think there is cause for concern.  If you disagree, please feel free to comment.  (Also, unlike some of the people I tend to criticize, I am open to disagreement.)

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

From the Campaign Trail: Not So Fast

I admit this was only my idea, but I really thought it would be a great thing for all of us if we had a substantial barrier along the train track, from 121st to Griffing/108th.  It seemed to me this would reduce the noise from the train, as well as the opportunity for intrusion from mischief-makers east of the track.  It seemed to me from all I heard that those mischief-makers very definitely do use that opportunity to come here, jump a fence or two, steal or vandalize, and scurry back.

So as I've made my way around, especially near the track, I've asked people about their experiences living on a train line.  I've been surprised at the responses.

The vast majority of our residents who live on or near the track say the same thing: at first it's bothersome, but you quickly enough get used to the noise.  These residents, some of whom are renters, and some of whom are owners, are frankly not complaining.  Not a lot, anyway.

As for intruders, most residents likewise don't see a significant problem.  The few who did report problems talked mostly about "kids" throwing rocks over fences.  It would take a pretty high wall to prevent something like that.

So one possibility is that perhaps it wouldn't be necessary to think about, and plan and save for, an expensive wall along the track.  I'll continue to talk to our police and to the most affected residents, whether I win a Commission seat or not, to see if the problem is less than I imagined.

The other possibility is that the kind of person who agrees to live along the track is essentially self-selected as someone who isn't likely to complain.  If such a person would find it unbearable, or even highly problematic, to live along a train track, he or she probably wouldn't have agreed to live there in the first place.  Or the lower rent and lower house prices made it worth it to deal with the train and the access from outsiders.  To be further explored.

The first house I ever bought, in Massachusetts, had a train track down the slope behind the back yard, about as far from the house as the FEC track is from BP houses.  I didn't like it at all.  And there were no mischief-makers, only noise and vibration.  So I was assuming our residents wouldn't like life on the track any more than I did.  Maybe I was wrong.  As I say, I'll continue to explore.