Wednesday, March 4, 2020

Apparently, the Answer is "No."


It's still a little bumpy at Commission meetings.  Ginny O'Halpin is still trying to get her rhythm and sense of command, and she gets help from various places.  To help herself, she relies more than is necessary on some of the suppressing methods of her predecessor.  I'm thinking particularly of her reliance on the three minute public comment clock.  Mac Kennedy, too, is a little more reliant on stringency than I thought he would be.  I'm not complaining.  I'm just making note.  Attorney John Herin is a lot of help.  Acting manager David Hernandez is less help than he thinks he is.  Roxy Ross was seated for the first meeting of her supposedly short fill-in term.  (I really hope she reconsiders, and runs in November, but it doesn't seem like she's willing to do it.)  She provided some grounding, too.  Although she and Ginny and Dan Samaria were having more inaudible pow-wows than they really should have, and it was a bit distracting.  Dan, by the way, is back from abdominal surgery, and he was close to fully functional.  He seemed a bit lost many times, but that happens to him sometimes anyway.

Will Tudor showed up.  Good, no one took my bet.  I would have lost.  Will is the last remaining Mohican, and his continued involvement on the Commission is a mystery.  If it was never about anything before (it never was), it's about even less now.  Betsy Wise pressed the "eject" button on herself, and Jenny Johnson-Sardella wasn't far behind.  With all the drama and disruption that had to accompany it, Her Royal Highness, the Empress Tracy (Big Mama) Truppman made her own dramatic exit.  It was complete with rumors that Tracy claimed to think her life was in danger, and undercurrent concerns that she might sue the Village (for who knows what).  And if she really might have, then she might still.  Whatever that could possibly turn out to be about.

So, as the dust was finally settling, and Will Tudor was either walking out of meetings, or missing them, I sent him an e-mail.  I asked him to do the right thing, and resign.  I asked him to do this just after Tracy resigned, and we thought we would have to have an election anyway, and it would be convenient to fill two seats, instead of just one.  But I never heard back from Will.  One theory was that since he no longer had a role or any identifiable meaning at Commission meetings, he would just run out the clock, continue to fail to show up at meetings until the Commission expelled him for too many unexcused absences, and he'd keep getting those checks from his neighbors' money for the extra few months.  But no, for who knows what reason, Will did show up last night.  The result of his being there or his not being there was the same thing, but he was there.

The meeting started with mention of Roxy Ross' return.  We were happy to have her back.  And because Roxy was there as a new Commissioner, we again voted for mayor.  Roxy nominated Ginny, who was already mayor, and no one nominated anyone else.  We now have a five person Commission.  And the vote to keep Ginny mayor was...4-1.  It didn't make any sense for Will to vote "no" on Ginny's election, and it didn't accomplish anything, but that's what Will chose to do.  It's true we "don't have [Tracy Truppman] to kick around any more," but Will made sure we didn't forget her.

And then, we had the big, big event of the evening.  Some of us wondered if Krishan Manners would show up to defend himself, or if he'd just fall on the sword Tracy carefully left sticking up for him.  He showed up.  It took us a good long time to rehash all the ugly material that was settled on Krishan.  And I know it wasn't Krishan's fault.  I know none of it was his idea.  Tracy Truppman, and her first lieutenant, Rebecca Rodriguez, set him up.  But he always did what his Mama told him to do.  And I always rooted for him not to.  But he needed his Mama, and that job, and that paycheck, a lot more than he needed to please me, or to make himself look like the decent person I know he really is.  So, it was one bad act after another.  And Krishan's assertions that nothing anyone said he did was true.  The end of it was that Roxy Ross made a motion to fire Krishan with cause (no settlement paid to him), and someone or other seconded.  And the vote was...4-1.  Will voted "no," and he did what anyone would have expected him to do.  He made empty excuses, and he threatened that firing Krishan would expose the Village to some unspoken legal jeopardy.  He was Tracy's boy, and he tried to defend Tracy's indefensible pet.

The rest of the meeting accomplished too little, and it took too long to do it.  We extended the meeting time twice.  Once, we extended from 11:00 to 11:30, and then, when we ran out of our extra 30 minutes, we extended for another 10.  And at that, we had several noteworthy agenda items untouched, so we have to have another meeting next week or the week after.  See you then?



6 comments:

  1. I forgot to mention that in the Commission's attempt to understand and highlight what Krishan did or didn't do, and why he did or didn't do it, Mac Kennedy and Roxy Ross were bright beacons. Both were focused, level-headed, and, in my opinion, completely respectful. I think they were very fair to Krishan, and they were fair to the Village. Each had a clear leaning, but each gave Krishan every opportunity to make his best case.

    On the "other side," a sizable Krishan contingent came out. They were shrill, not focused, and not reality-based.

    The bottom line, which was identically, but oppositely, stated by Uta Nicht (sp?) and me, was that Krishan was not treated fairly by the Commission. Uta didn't think Krishan was treated fairly by the present Commission, and I didn't think he was treated fairly by the preceding one.

    Tracy set Krishan up, and she had him do things she knew shouldn't have been done. She hid behind him, and she "threw him under the bus," as they say. I wanted Krishan to tell her no. I wanted him to quit, or to let her fire him. I like Krishan. I wanted him saved, and I wanted him to save himself. I told him this. But Krishan makes his own decisions, for his own reasons, and he chose to take a bullet for Tracy. As I said last night, I very deeply regret what happened to Krishan, and what happened to the Village. But it wasn't up to me.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Couple of observations.

    As far as Tudor is concerned I think he feels like he finally fits in, allow me to explain. During the previous commission he was no one, not really allowed to talk or have an opinion. Suddenly even if its to play the the roll of the bad guy in the WWF he has found a voice. He feels as the elder statesman and will play to the Utas of the World, good luck with that!

    Now on to Krishan. I think you're right there is a good guy in there somewhere but also a weak guy. Having managed over 600 employees and 30 or more managers at any given time I have had to fire many nice people over the years because they were simply not competent to do the job. I think Krishan was in over his head from day one. I also believe that like many other Managers I have witnessed in the past they will mold into whomever is above them. If they have a great leader they will do great, if they have an awful leader they will follow their lead. Some people make the decision to stand on there own two feet and others need to lean on others for support, and acceptance.

    Last night I kept thinking of Ronald Reagan (I dont recall) and Lt. Col. Oliver North (the fall guy) Krishan played both rolls last night. I wish him the very best and I hope he finds a great job with a great leader, I am sure he will do just fine.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Art, Krishan is weak, without question. He was hired for that quality. Tracy needed a secretary and someone to do legwork, and that's what she hired Krishan for. I have said all along, and I will say again, that no one knows whether or not Krishan is competent, or knows or could learn how to be a manager. He was not hired to be competent, or to take initiative, or to tell Tracy anything. He was hired to be her boy, and that's what he was. Can he? Could he? Unknown. And the new Commissioners weren't waiting to find out. They were furious, including at him, and they cleaned house. The reason I have no argument with them is that Krishan should have said no to Tracy. He should have quit. He should have let Tracy fire him. He should not have complied. The fact that he did what he did is on him. I say the same thing about Sarah Sanders. I don't criticize her for lying. Her boss was a liar, and she had to represent him. I criticize her for being willing to take the job. That's my criticism of Krishan. If you agree to take the job, whether you're Krishan or Christina Caserta, you're a henchman. You do bad and nasty, and illegal, things. That's what your boss requires of you, and you do it if you stay in the job.

      I have absolutely no use for Tudor. I never did, and he's shown me nothing. Not ever, and not last night. He was a pathetic apologist, and he couldn't even do the obvious thing of voting to keep Ginny mayor. Who did this "elder statesman" think should be mayor? Himself? Give me a break. If it was anyone other than Ginny, it could only have been Roxy. If Tudor had wanted Roxy to be mayor, he would have nominated her. He's a wholly unworthy Commissioner, and he should have done what I asked him to do: resign. He has zero role and zero impact.

      Delete
  3. One person hired under this regime that stood his ground is the Police Chief, although he may have been on the chopping block many times he stood his ground.

    ReplyDelete
  4. From Chuck Ross:

    After Tuesday night's performance, Will's new name is Dr. No. He gets a dis-honorable degree in, "No is the answer what's the question". Per your example, what was the purpose to vote no against keeping Ginny as Mayor, as opposed to who else, as there no other nomination was offered.? What a class act. I also have a few questions about his interaction with Krishan, he acted as if he was his defense attorney. The interaction appeared to be coordinated.

    It's been a long while since I think of Krishan as a nice person. I have learned over the past year or two that not only is he not nice, he has a nasty devious dark side (NDDS). This showed itself most recently, when the former Manager, Krishan, was given the opportunity to let the Dan issue go and admit defeat after the judge dismissed the case Krishan, I'm sure with Tracy's prodding brought against Dan. Instead, Krishan, Rebecca and Tracy (KRT) went on the attack. At least a week prior to the day Dan was evicted (Jan 31st), Dan obtained a place to live, in the event he was locked out of the house where he resided. KRT learned of this and arranged for a subpoena to be issued demanding the landlord appear for a deposition. The result was the landlord returned Dan's rent and deposit. Apparently, she did not want to be in the middle and possibly become targeted by the Village. The strategy worked, at least temporarily. Dan now had to find another place to nest and KRT could make the argument, flawed as it was*, that he was soon to be without a permanent place to live in BP.

    The K in KRT appeared to be all over this, I don’t think this was T alone telling him what to do at this point. From the e-mails I read, this was K taking the lead and directing R. This is not the behavior of a nice guy. He had several opportunities along the way, to step back and walk away from the KRT alliance, but he took the dark and devious route instead. E-mails show that K, apparently alone, using R, was ready to pounce and continue to legally pursue Dan, after the lawsuit had been throw out by the Judge. K truly has a NDDS. BTW, K, again using R (unless R acted on her own), threatened to legally go after Dan’s attorney that helped him.

    K showed his true colors again at the Commission meeting Tuesday night, when he alleged that Rox had a conflict because one of her Bosses took such offence to the way Dan was treated, that he took the “Dan case” on for free, including case costs. K’s attitude Tuesday night in general was snarky and contentious.

    Based on these and other actions, K is not a nice guy.

    As it turned out, in the end Dan located a long-term place to rent in BP, the next day, Feb 1st and KRT was effectively stopped. Will KRT re-emerge to attempt to generate more damage to the Village? Time will tell.

    The bottom line, T resigned, R was reassigned from the Village account by the law firm that shortly thereafter resigned from the Village, K was suspended and on Tuesday night terminated.

    *Based on a legal Memo from Miami Shores, there are numerous legal cases that have established common law, that residency is not lost overnight, or for that matter over several months in some cases, if your intent is to return as a resident, where you originally resided.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Chuck,

      I can't argue with you. I know what you know, and I'm sure I come across as naive, but I feel as if I knew Krishan when... And I think I know what happened to him. Krishan is not the only person who was trampled and bamboozled by Tracy. We had almost a whole Commission of them. We still have one left.

      As for your "KRT," I would have said TRK. It could make you think of trick, or truck. The ringleader was never K. It was always T.

      But I agree with you, and with Mac and Ginny and anyone else who wanted Krishan out: he did some very not nice things. And it's fair to say that it doesn't matter whether his bad acts were his own idea, or he was carrying out someone else's destructive missions. As I already said, he should have refused. He didn't. He's guilty. Even if he says that everyone who has a story to tell is wrong, or that he just doesn't remember. And he's said both.

      Yes, it was a very cheap dodge to suggest that Rox, or Drew, had a conflict of interest. I certainly never heard him suggest that about Rebecca, whose outrageous bills he kept approving. And I never heard him express concern about Tracy's unbelievably heavy reliance on almost nonstop legal consultation, and whether there was some conflict of interest there.

      No, you're right. Krishan's actions were not those of a nice guy. I still think he got caught up in something that wasn't natural for him, but he did get caught up in it. He allowed that to happen. And he accepted a bonus that didn't make sense. He doesn't seem to have wondered whether he himself had some conflict of interest.

      Fred

      Delete