Monday, June 24, 2024

ALL HANDS ON DECK!

I think I'll start this post as follows: it is commonly said that if you want to attend quality cultural events, you must go to NYC.  You can hear music (classical, jazz, or anything else), see plays, or attend dance shows.  You can go to art shows, museums, and galleries.  In my experience, this conclusion is insane.  There is so much culture going on in Miami that you can attend one thing or another most days, you sometimes have to choose which thing (same day, and same time) you want to attend, even occasionally at the same venue, and I have on uncommon occasion attended more than one event on the same day.  There are many small companies, some larger ones, and the County has even erected venues where none existed before.  I've made things easier on myself by not going to any event that requires me to buy a ticket from TicketMaster or Eventbrite, usually not going to Miami Beach (the Colony Theater and New World Symphony, and often the bandshell), not going to the Arsht, because the ticket prices are too high, and parking is too difficult, and I've stopped attending some shows I otherwise like, because I didn't approve of their evolving artistic direction.  And even so, I'm busy a lot!  So no one will be at a lack for artistic activities in South Florida, or even just Dade County.

This morning, I received an e-mail from Dimensions Dance Theater of Miami.  I have no doubt I've mentioned them repeatedly before.  Almost all of their shows I see are at South Miami-Dade Cultural Arts Center (also called Dennis C Moss Cultural Arts Center).  It's far from here, in Cutler Bay, but it's very well worth the trip.  This e-mail was almost identical to an e-mail I received last week from Dance NOW! Miami, which is an extremely similar company.  And there will be more.  (I just now got another one from GableStage.)

It turns out that Florida's best known adult-aged child, Ronnie DeSantis, has cut all or nearly all state grants from cultural organizations.  Specifically, he has eliminated $32M in grants.  I wouldn't begin to guess what this game feels like to Ronnie, but it has very significant consequences for Florida arts organizations.

And let me explain to you how arts funding works.  At the very best, arts organizations (all of them, including the Louvre, the New York City Ballet, the Cleveland Symphony Orchestra, and every other one there is) make at most 30% of their budget by selling tickets.  The rest of their budget comes from grants and donations.  In Florida, until now, grants came from the (federal) National Endowment for the Arts (NEA), the state, the county, the municipality, and grant providers like the Knight Foundation.  And applying for a grant doesn't mean the organization gets one.  Generally speaking -- again until now -- everyone has valued the arts (the Dade County Commissions have been magnificent), and among ticket sales, grants, and personal donations, I don't know of one that has failed.  The e-mails I got last week and today are emergency alerts.  Arts organizations are now in more trouble than they used to be, thanks to Ronnie DeSantis and his tricycle.

No arts organization can raise ticket prices to fulfill its budget.  Ticket prices would be so high that no one would attend.  The organizations still get federal, county, municipality, and grant provider grants, except for the state now, so what has to change is donations.  Donations come from people like you and me.  Some people who have or had a lot of money leave ongoing donations, even after they die.  But not all of them do.  I knew a guy like that, who was always a generous donor to several arts organizations.  But he and his wife died, and he remembered some, but not all, of those organizations in his will.  And at least one of the ones he stopped remembering operates on a shoestring.  So they're in trouble now.

I will give you what would normally be confidential information.  My largest donation is to musimelange.  I donate $2500 per year, on top of the $300 per year I pay for four concerts, because musimelange is an extraordinarily unique organization, it has a very small audience (almost what you might call intimate), and the founder is a friend of mine.  If you're keeping up with the arithmetic, I pay $700 per evening, which includes all the top flight wine I want, all the gourmet food/"bites" I want, a spectacular concert, all the excellent champagne I want, all the French dessert I want, I support my friend, and I get to experience this with nice and interesting people, including some BP residents, and others of whom become friends.  Is that worth $700 per evening?  Probably not to some, but it it is to me.  I donate $1000 to each of two organizations (I'm on the Board of one), and lesser amounts to others.  I commonly gave $250 a year to Dance NOW! Miami, but after last week's e-mail, I doubled it.  And most of these organizations do not have pre-publicized "seasons" to which you can subscribe.  As I said, things are so busy down here that it's hit or miss as to whether or not you can go, and how often.  The donation is commonly your biggest contribution.

My system is this: if I like an organization enough to go to its shows, I subscribe to its season, if it has one.  If I subscribe, I donate.  (And if it doesn't have a season, I donate anyway.)  As I said, the donation is not uncommonly, or is most commonly, larger than the subscription price.  I know that sounds nuts, but it has to be that way.  Otherwise, they don't survive.  And if you go to them, you'll hope very much that they do survive.

How much do you donate?  It depends on a lot of things.  But I'll tell you this.  If you look at lists of donors mentioned in programs, you'll see in a number of programs that people who donate $50 per year are listed.  That's how much these organizations need the donations, and how grateful they are to get them.  Not that they wouldn't be more grateful to get $100, or $150, or $250, or $500, or more.  There are personal donors who donate $10K or more per year.  (I've seen some programs that list some of the performers as donors (they get paid to perform, then they donate back part of what they got paid).  Everybody gets it.  Everybody except Ronnie DeSantis, who must be a very ill-tempered, and probably unhappy and angry, person, and probably needs an appointment with me.

Anyway, don't waste your time and money going to NYC.  You can have all the enrichment you want, in three languages, right here.  And make a donation.  It's now desperately needed.


6 comments:

  1. It occurs to me that I should add that I had been leaning on the founder of musimelange to encourage patrons to donate. But the founder is inhibited about that, and at the last concert, she asked me to talk to her audience. So among the things I said was that I play what I called a "dumb game" with musimelange, and with other arts organizations I patronize. I subscribe to the whole season, and as early as possible, so I can be the best discount. Then, I donate far more than I saved. (I think my discount is about $80. As I told you, my donation is $2500.) Getting a discount is fun. Donating is necessary.

    Sometimes, you can't donate. (That's why I'm happy to pay taxes.) You can't donate to County venues, or the Koubek Center, which is owned by Miami-Dade College. A lot of people donated to the Arsht. There are loads of plaques naming donors, and the Arsht was first called the Caribbean Center or something, after some cruise line, until Ms Arsht donated even more. In a different arena, so to speak, that's why the stadium where the Dolphins play has gotten a string of names, every time someone donates more. The Heat play in the "American Airlines Arena." Do you want to guess who donated money for that?

    But those are millions or many millions of dollars. A few hundred are greatly appreciated by Dimensions, Dance NOW! Miami, GableStage. and various others. My list also includes Ballet Flamenco La Rosa, Siempre Flamenco, Miami Light Project, and some others. None of those, except GableStage, has a predictable season, so I just hope I make it to some of their shows. I used to be a stalwart for Seraphic Fire (full season), but I couldn't bear sitting on wooden pews any more. The music is off the charts, and they're all super nice people. I might just not go, but donate anyway. I also used to go to Miami Symphony Orchestra and Nu Deco (both full seasons), but I couldn't keep up with the artistic direction they were taking. But I do host out of town musicians for Nu Deco. That saves them money, and I've made some very nice friends that way.

    ReplyDelete
  2. A huge thank you, Fred!!! As you know I am a.huge fan of Dimensions Dance Theater of Miami and the remarkable work that Jennifer, Carlos, choreographers and dancers are producing. They and other small companies MUST survive! It’s up to us, each of us as individuals, to do what we can.
    Karen Alexander

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A spectacular group of people, Karen. I was sorry to see Natanael go (although I did see him dancing for someone else recently at Sandrell Rivers), and Jennifer told me Daniel White is now a manager at a Starbucks, because it pays better. I'm very impressed to see how much better and more sophisticated Yanis Eric's choreography has gotten.

      I have some art to sell or give away, and I gave Jennifer and Carlos one large painting done by a dancer who became a painter. It's a painting of people dancing. I've been trying to give the other one to Hannah and Diego, but I can't get them to come get it, and I'm tired of asking. So I might offer that one to Jennifer and Carlos, too.

      There are some magnificent dancers down here, and some have stayed with Jennifer and Carlos for some years (Selah and Chloe come to mind). I think one of them even had a baby, and has returned to dancing.

      Delete
  3. I forgot to mention the federal grants, from the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA).

    Also, I'm on the Board of Orchestra Miami, and I have leaned on the founder and artistic director, and conductor, and pianist, to raise ticket prices. They're way too low. But she likes OM to be easily accessible, even to families, and some of the events that aren't underpriced are free. When I was asked to join the Board, I asked how much I would be expected to donate. (There are arts Boards you can't join unless you donate $10K a year, and I can't afford that.) She said $600, and it can be "in kind." (If I happen to be an accountant, I can "donate" whatever I claim is $600 worth of accounting services.) So I told her this was not acceptable, she should demand at least $1000 per Board member (which is what I donate), and get a larger Board. I don't know what she did about the former, but she's working on the latter. I even know someone who could easily afford it, and has worked with the founder's brother, but he wasn't interested in joining the Board. Or going to concerts. It's not easy to keep this machinery running, and Ronnie just made it harder, especially in South Florida, which has loads of arts organizations, and not nearly as many Republicans. Probably just a coincidence, right?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh, I also donate to the Association of Performing Arts of India (APAI), on which I used to be on the Board. But Board meetings were at the house of the founder and her husband up in west Broward, and I didn't feel like driving there any more. I attend every concert I can, and when the founder needs a donation, she calls me. I generally give her between $100 and $500. The ticket price is about $30 or $40. I have never attended one concert that wasn't amazing -- they're classical Indian music -- and a number of them include dinner at some Indian restaurant (my favorite food, by far) after the show. And the concerts tend to run 2-3 hours. She even brought in Zakir Hussein one time, which is like bringing in the Beatles or the Rolling Stones. That concert was in a large auditorium in Palm Beach County, and I think she filled it.

    I used to donate $1000 a year to the Miami Light Project, when they had a more active and predictable season, and I had more money, but I've reduced it. I occasionally make it to their events, which mostly occur now at the Miami Theater Center in Miami Shores.

    I don't get to Siempre Flamenco as much as I used to, and their shows tend to be at the bandshell on Miami Beach (which I don't like, because it's outside and sometimes too noisy), but I still donate. It's not a lot -- maybe $100-$200 per year -- and their shows are not expensive to produce, but as with everything else, you just have to donate what you can. I used to have more money in those days, so I didn't care.

    I don't know what they're ever going to do with the Coconut Grove Playhouse, but that's a County venue, too. So you can't donate beyond paying your taxes. But there are lots of venues. I've gone to several events at the Sanctuary of the Arts, which is a Coral Gables church that some guy (the husband of one of my medical school classmates) turned into an arts venue, but I heard a well-sourced rumor that he's trying to prevent the Coconut Grove Playhouse from succeeding, so I don't go there any more. But he's had some wonderful shows. The topic of donating never arose. But he's a lawyer, so he probably has more money than he knows what to do with anyway.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have now also gotten e-mails from Seraphic Fire and Fantasy Theatre Factory (which is the main or only tenant of Sandrell Rivers Theater).

    It was made clear that DeSantis canceled all state grants for every arts organization in Florida.

    ReplyDelete